Lee Odden

Future of Online PR and Reputation Management

For this post I am using for inspiration (with attribution) a recent post headline from Steve Rubel, “The Future of PR is Participation, Not Pitching“. As with most “this tactic is dead” posts, I think the reality is that while pitching the media as we know it today is in decline, it will always provide value as a method of communicating story ideas to journalists. It’s the method or technology that will change such as pitching with Del.icio.us or RSS rather than a phone call.

After speaking about various aspects of marketing and PR through social media at a search marketing, public relations and a direct marketing conference in the past 2 months, I can see there’s no doubt the “participatory web” is hot on the minds of many company marketers, agencies and vendors that serve this market.

Which brings me to a series of questions Andy Beal recently asked me in regard to a book he’s writing on reputation management. They were great questions and the topics are not only relevant to managing a reputation online, but also resonate well with how online PR, search and social marketing are changing in accordance with shifts in how people create, consume, re-purpose and share information.

It really is a matter of no longer having control over your message or brand and more about the importance of participating in the dialogue.

Changes in Public Relations in an Online World:
Many Public Relations practitioners are scrambling to adjust to the opportunities presented by shifts in consumer behavior online. After speaking at the largest media relations conference in the world recently, (Media Relations Summit), I’ve seen firsthand how the PR industry is making a concerted effort to educate itself about new PR channels such as search engine marketing and marketing with social media.

Some PR agencies have been able to fully embrace these shifts at their core, and not only become successfully involved with online communities but have been instrumental at facilitating PR’s role in the various online channels such as social networking, blogs and search. These agencies are best prepared to represent brands in a win win situation over those firms that skim social media with tactics and without a full understanding of the medium. The work of Chris Heuer, Todd Defren, Brian Solis and our own PR practice come to mind.

Not fully understanding social media communities for example, has resulted in brand damage rather than audience engagement. Look no further than the various brand embarrassments as a result of fake blogs, user accounts on social news sites and fake social network participation. In a way, the way to effectively get covered in an online media world is to become the media, ie, embrace the online culture of user generated media. Participation and transparency are the lighthouses for an online PR future.

Emerging Online PR Tactics:
Email and smile/dial pitching as we know it may be on the way out, but journalists will always benefit from reputable sources and being presented with great story ideas relevant to their audiences.

Technology has increasingly provided PR practitioners with tools to make it easier for journalists and the media to cover their clients’ news. RSS and blogs for example, provide excellent channels as well as the social bookmarking of concentrated clusters of information. The social media news release attempts to achieve this effect, but has yet to be accepted as a standard format.

When establishing a relationship with a particular publication or journalist, including links to short podcast and video interviews in email pitches have proven productive in that they provide examples of what it might be like to interview executives relevant to company news and provide sound bites. Subsequently hosting these various media using blog software in the form of an online media room makes the content discoverable on its own via traditional search as well as social media channels.

However, regardless of effective technology is for communications, there is no substitute for human contact whether it’s in person or via phone. In the end, technology can only facilitate what’s been important for the media since day one of the PR business: Find reliable sources and interesting story ideas that help the publication serve it’s readership and advertisers.

Media Training, Blogger Relations and Spin:

Since we’re running both a search marketing agency and a public relations firm, we’ve always counseled our clients on the use of targeted keywords during interviews and in communications with the media. These are the keywords we’ve optimized their content for. When the interviews or articles are published on or offline, many readers will remember the topic after reading, but not the names of the companies mentioned. We’ve found that it’s fairly common that readers go to Google and search the topic of the article whereupon our clients have prominent visibility in the search results.

Blogger relations is a slippery slope when approached with traditional media relations tactics. Most bloggers have no use for a typical email pitch. For successful blogger relations, more effort must be undertaken into qualifying bloggers to determine their degree of influence and what’s important to them as well as their readers. Pitching is customized and personal by default, not as an exception.

Most PR professionals grew up in the industry on spin so it takes a bit of re-training to get tenured staff in the habit of participation and transparency. Blogger relations is a never ending task of practice and refinement. PR is still about persuasion though, so there will always be some aspect of the pitching effort designed for a particular messaging outcome. That’s not spin as we know it today, but it is still a sale to be made.

Crisis Communications Has Changed:

In the past, PR professionals could call their contacts within the media to keep a negative story from getting coverage. With more and more editorial decisions in the hands of user generated content, there’s nothing any company or PR professional can do to stop negative news from being posted, ranted, commented and spread.

Todays participatory web requires companies to be involved with online communities in order to gain any kind of foothold on what’s being said and discussed about their brands. The notion that, “Conversations are happening with or without you, so get involved or get left behind”, rings true for brands and PR as well as for advertising and marketing.

Brands need to be monitored continuously and when dissention is detected, it must be qualified and responded to quickly. Corporate PR and communications need to allocate ongoing resources to this end in proportion to the value of their brand equity. The bigger the brand, the more you have to lose by not paying attention to what social communities and the blogosphere is saying.

Additional resources on reputation management online:

Reputation Management – Wikipedia
Basics of Reputation Management – TopRank
Online Reputation Monitoring & Management Beginners Guide – Marketing Pilgrim

PoorSo SoOKGoodAwesome (2 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)

Lee Odden About Lee Odden

@LeeOdden is the CEO of TopRank Marketing and editor of Online Marketing Blog. Cited for his expertise by The Economist, Forbes and the Wall Street Journal, he's the author of the book Optimize and presents internationally on B2B marketing topics including content, search, social media and influencer marketing. When not at conferences, consulting, or working with his talented team, he's likely running, traveling or cooking up something new.


  1. Avatar Mario Bonilla says

    Great post Lee. The evolving nature of communications online is difficult for a boomer like myself to keep up with. You provide a clear, calm voice that makes it easier to keep up with it all. Thanks

  2. Great post Lee. The Shift in the way PR is done making services like Social Media Management and Reputation management more and more popular

  3. Steve Rubel and I were both on a panel yesterday afternoon at the Wharton School. The participation vs. pitching subject came up there, too. My take is that participation is the new option that wasn’t available before social media like blogs came along. But, pitching won’t disappear until mainstream media do. The debate on this was prompted by a question from Wharton’s Marketing Professor Pete Fader, who asked: Earlier this year, Arthur Ochs Sulzberger Jr., the publisher and chairman of the New York Times Company, told an interviewer, “I really don’t know whether we’ll be printing The Times in five years, and you know what? I don’t care.” Will the newspaper as we know it be dead by 2012? Who knowns. In the meantime, keep pitching reporters while you are participating in blogs. Both still work.

  4. Nice post… saw lots of blogs in your list.. sad mine not in there too =(

    Keep it up =)

  5. That is actually a good post. Thanks. also sad mine is not included in there lol.

  6. Avatar Susan Gosselin says

    I am a p.r. consultant and I have been working very hard to move my clients toward social networking media. I’m having some success. However, I recently completed a phone survey of the entire media list for one of my Fortune 100 clients. With only one or two exceptions, NO ONE wanted to receive our information by RSS feed. Their argument was they did not want to get a bunch of information they did not want…only the stories we felt they would conceivably run. This is a common issue among very large companies with very large product portfolios. Now, I suppose I could slice and dice the list up into little RSS communities. But frankly, that’s really no different than sending a release out to a set mailing list. Believe me, if I could find some way to cut down on my smile and dialin, that would make me pretty damn happy. But the bottom line, even for the large national pubs, is that they still want to feel like there is some personalization to what’s being pitched to them. You know…like you know what they like to write about and are putting together something just for their needs. I think the RSS feed strategy works well for public companies sharing standard stockholder information. And it works well for clients who have a rather narrow product base.

    I would love to hear from other p.r. pros about their experiences with automating pitching through RSS. Perhaps there is something I’m missing here.

  7. Alvin, that’s because you have more ads than content and the subject matter isn’t focused on search marketing.

  8. Hey Susan, I think you’re spot on about personalization.

    At the same time, with journalists increasingly expected to do more with less, technology such as RSS (used in the right way) compliments what’s already working in the pitching game.

    RSS isn’t replacing the email/phone call pitch, but making content available in that format provides additional distribution options (blog and standard search engines) as well as a channel for those publications where receiving info via RSS is a good fit.

  9. Hi Greg, is that the panel you asked me to speak on?

  10. Yes, Lee, this is the panel that you were asked to be on. The Wharton School plans to hold the Full-Spectrum Innovation workshop again Jan 28-30, 2008. Imagine, Steve Rubel, you and me on the same panel! That would be worth blogging about.

  11. Greg, that would be fantastic!

  12. Great Post Lee!

    We are in the process of developing a new “hands-on” rep management program for a few large brands in the hotel industry. Because I deal w/ Reputation Management every day, I’m amazed at the lack of “investment” in the long-term viability of a brand.

    By investing in CGM and Reputation – a brand can build on something they own and can (hopefully) trademark vs. building a whole foundation on some keywords that may or may-not continue to gain market share. I think BOTH tactics are viable but putting all your eggs in one “basket” is ill-advised. Hopefully your article can open some eyes on this subject.


  13. Good point Carrie. One thing I failed to mention in the post was something I heard Phil Gomes from Edelman say at the Media Relations Summit: Getting involved with consumer generated content and social media communities is only useful as an brand protection effort if it’s proactive, not reactive.

    There’s more than one company out there that has felt the sting of an influential blogger and then decided to start a blog and become involved with the community after the fact. Better to be proactive and participate now even without specific ROI goals.

  14. Great post, Lee, and great comment about “pro-active vs. re-active”. One (not “all”) of the ways to avoid having to do “re-active” reputation management is by “Setting Realistic, Deliverable, and Measurable Expectations”. Both sellers and buyers have to do it properly in today’s ever growing connected and networked world. Bloggers with even a small degree of influence can be found, and socially networked on, through their right use of keywords within quality content.

  15. Great Post on Future of Online PR and Reputation Management.

  16. Good article Lee 🙂

    The virtual world has indeed changed the way a company’s reputation should be managed. Like what you mentioned Lee, PR consultants can’t contact their networks within the media to keep a negative story from going out when it comes to the web.

    Good idea for PR consultants to arm themselves with SEO tactics to manage their clients’ reputation.


  1. […] Online Marketing Blog: Future of Online PR and Reputation Management “Not fully understanding social media communities for example, has resulted in brand damage rather than audience engagement. Look no further than the various brand embarrassments as a result of fake blogs, user accounts on social news sites and fake social network participation. In a way, the way to effectively get covered in an online media world is to become the media, ie, embrace the online culture of user generated media. Participation and transparency are the lighthouses for an online PR future.” […]

  2. […] I tend to hit the middle of the road when it comes to “this tactic is dead” types of posts. The “pitching is dead, long live participation” idea was no different, so I did a post at our Online Marketing Blog, “The Future of Online PR and Reputation Management” to dig a bit deeper into the continued need for traditional pitching in combination with the use of technology and social community/blogosphere involvement. […]

  3. This Week In SEO - 6/29/07 - TheVanBlog says:

    […] Future of Online PR and Reputation Management […]

  4. Naked PR » Blog Archive » Blog Buzz on PR: 7/1/07 says:

    […] The Future of Online PR and Reputation Management […]

  5. Now Is Gone » The Art of Participation Public Relations says:

    […] Online Marketing Blog: Future of Online PR and Reputation Management […]

  6. […] Future of Online PR and Reputation Management […]

  7. […] Future of Online PR and Reputation Management by Lee Odden at Top Rank […]

  8. Enterprise business social media for entrepreneurs -seo-smo-smm : 123 Social Media says:

    […] Definitive Guide to Online Reputation Management Future of Online PR and Reputation Management 10 Ways to “Own Yourself” […]